When you choose the right Search Engine Optimization partner, your online visibility will grow and so will your traffic.
But before you sign a contract, you’ll see a proposal.
That document should tell you everything you need to know about how the agency works, what they plan to do, and how they’ll measure success.
The problem? Most SEO proposals look the same on the surface.
They’re filled with jargon, checklists, and vague promises.
In this AI-evolved environment, that won’t cut it.
With AI-driven search reshaping how websites earn visibility, you need an agency that understands both technical SEO and AI discoverability.
This post breaks down what an SEO proposal is, what it should include today, and how to read between the lines before you make your choice.
What Is an SEO Proposal?
An SEO proposal is a detailed plan outlining how an agency or consultant intends to improve your website’s search visibility.
It’s more than a price quote. It’s a strategy blueprint.
A proper SEO proposal should tell you:
- What the agency understands about your current visibility and competition
- How they plan to improve rankings and organic traffic
- What tools, tactics, and AI-driven methods they use
- How they will measure results over time
- What it will cost, and what you’ll get for that investment
It’s a preview of how the agency thinks, operates, and communicates.
If the proposal looks generic, expect the work to feel the same.
Why SEO Proposals Have Changed
AI is now part of every major search engine.
Google’s Search Generative Experience, Bing Copilot, and ChatGPT’s web integrations have changed how people discover information.
SEO strategies written five years ago are outdated.
Modern SEO proposals must account for:
- Entity recognition (how Google and AI models interpret your brand, services, and expertise)
- Structured data and semantic markup (the language machines use to understand context)
- Answer Engine Optimization (how your content appears in AI-generated answers)
- Generative Engine Optimization (how your brand gets cited in ChatGPT, Perplexity, and other LLM tools)
If the proposal doesn’t mention AI-driven visibility or semantic optimization, it’s behind the curve.
Key Elements Every SEO Proposal Should Include
Let’s look at what a complete, trustworthy proposal should contain in 2025 and how to tell when something’s missing.
1. Executive Summary
This section should recap what the agency learned about your business, website, and goals.
If it feels boilerplate or lacks detail about your niche, they probably didn’t research you properly.
Look for:
- A clear understanding of your audience / ICP
- Competitor references based on real data
- Mentions of your core challenges or missed opportunities
A proposal that speaks your language builds instant trust. One that could apply to anyone isn’t worth your time.
2. Website and SEO Audit Findings
Before an agency makes recommendations, they should analyze your current state. That includes:
- Technical SEO health
- Indexation and crawlability
- Page speed and Core Web Vitals
- Structured data markup
- Content quality and topic relevance
- Backlink authority
- Local visibility (if applicable)
Today, the best agencies also include AI-readiness metrics.
That means auditing how your content will perform in AI-generated responses or Google AI Overviews.
If this section looks thin or focuses only on keyword counts, the analysis is shallow.
3. Strategy and Roadmap
This is the heart of the proposal. It should explain how the agency plans to improve your organic visibility, both short- and long-term.
Strong proposals outline:
- Keyword and entity optimization based on intent, not just volume
- Content strategy that blends human storytelling with AI-assisted ideation
- Technical improvements that enhance site speed, UX, and structured data
- Authority building through quality backlinks and digital PR
- Performance tracking with transparent KPIs tied to business outcomes
By now, every serious SEO roadmap also references AEO and GEO, because discoverability across AI platforms now drives traffic and credibility.
4. Deliverables and Timelines
A proposal should spell out exactly what you’re paying for and when to expect it. Avoid vague lists like “ongoing optimization” or “content updates.”
You should see specifics such as:
- Number of pages optimized
- Content deliverables (blogs, landing pages, schema updates)
- Audit or reporting cadence
- Timelines for each major phase
If the proposal lacks milestones or accountability, it’s a red flag.
5. Tools and Technology
Every agency uses SEO software, but not all use it intelligently. A future-ready proposal should list the stack that powers their strategy and explain why it matters.
Expect to see tools for:
- Keyword and entity research (SEMrush, Ahrefs, or in-house AI tools)
- Site auditing and technical monitoring (Screaming Frog, Sitebulb, JetOctopus for Enterprise)
- Rank tracking across traditional search and AI platforms
- Content optimization powered by AI or NLP models
- Reporting dashboards with live performance data
An agency that integrates AI tools responsibly, with human review and validation, will outperform those that don’t.
6. Reporting and Performance Measurement
Measurement defines accountability. An SEO proposal should show exactly how the agency plans to track progress.
Modern reporting covers:
- Organic traffic trends
- Entity presence in AI and search ecosystems
- Share of voice in AI-generated answers
- Conversions from organic traffic
- Technical health metrics over time
Look for clear language and sample dashboards. If an agency hides behind vanity metrics, they’re avoiding the real conversation about ROI.
7. Pricing and Scope
This section should be transparent and logical. Beware of SEO proposals that:
- Bundle too many deliverables for unrealistically low prices
- Hide key details under “custom pricing”
- Offer “guaranteed rankings” (no one can guarantee that)
A credible SEO partner prices based on value, not guesswork. Expect pricing models tied to:
- Campaign size and complexity
- Geographic scope
- Industry competitiveness
- Ongoing optimization vs. one-time projects
In 2025, many agencies also include optional AI-enhanced deliverables such as predictive insights or LLM-driven keyword expansion. Those add value when executed correctly.
Red Flags in an SEO Proposal
Not every proposal deserves your time.
Watch out for these warning signs:
- Overpromising or guaranteeing rankings
- Avoiding technical discussion
- Using vague phrases like “secret tactics” or “proprietary methods”
- Ignoring structured data or AI visibility
- Missing mention of how reporting works
- Pricing that looks too good to be real
If a proposal checks any of those boxes, it’s time to move on.
How to Choose the Right SEO Partner
Once you’ve reviewed a few proposals, compare them side by side.
Don’t focus only on cost. Focus on clarity, accountability, and long-term potential.
Ask yourself:
- Do they understand my business and audience?
- Are they transparent about methods and timelines?
- Do they measure results in ways that match my goals?
- Do they address AI-driven visibility and not just traditional SEO?
The best proposal won’t be the cheapest.
It’ll be the one that shows you exactly how they’ll earn results and why their approach works.
Final Thoughts
An SEO proposal in 2025 should feel less like a pitch and more like a plan.
It should prove the agency understands both human search behavior and AI-powered discovery systems.
If you finish reading one and feel confident they can improve your visibility, not just your rankings, you’ve found a real partner.
When in doubt, remember this rule: Transparency, expertise, and a clear Human + AI strategy always win.
Get your SEO proposal from Return On Now, an agency who understands modern search, here.
Frequently Asked Questions About SEO Proposals
Tommy Landry
Latest posts by Tommy Landry (see all)
- What Is an SEO Proposal and What Should It Include? - December 2, 2025
- The Complete Guide to Dental SEO: How Dentists Can Attract More Local Patients Online - November 25, 2025
- How AI Is Changing eCommerce SEO and Product Discoverability - November 20, 2025
